Gourmet Fudge by flavor

Our fudge recipe was created over 40 years ago and has been known as America's Best Fudge since the early '80s. Our ingredients must be pure and natural. Our fudge will always be made in the small-batch tradition, hand-stirred in copper kettles cooked over an open flame. This cooking method creates a silky smooth fudge that has been recognized as America's finest.

WE MAKE EVERY SLICE WITH CARE

Sort by

Limited Batch

Lemon Meringue Fudge

$ 0.00 - $ 0.00

$ 0.00

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

In stock

Make summer sweeter than ever with the new flavor of the month - Lemon Meringue Fudge! Satisfy your sweet tooth with this delightful, zesty treat t...

View full details

$ 0.00 - $ 0.00

$ 0.00

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Limited Batch

Watermelon Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Bring the taste of summer to every bite. Watermelon Fudge combines juicy, refreshing watermelon with creamy fudge for a flavor that's bold, playful...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

LIMITED BATCH

Bananas Foster Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Bananas Foster Fudge captures the essence of a classic dessert in every bite. Rich, creamy fudge infused with ripe bananas, melted butter, brown su...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Black Cherry Bourbon Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Our Black Cherry Bourbon fudge is cooked in two different batches taking double the time than our single batch flavors. With all good things take t...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Orange Creamsicle Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Can you remember what a fresh orange creamsicle popsicle tasted like? Well, this tastes just like that except it's not cold...Unless you like your...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Strawberry Cheesecake Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

One of our most popular summer flavors, a kid's favorite, and those that just love the taste of creamy strawberry cheesecake made with real strawb...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Raspberry Chocolate Truffle Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Tastes like the best chocolate truffle you’ve ever had, but with a fruity twist. The perfect balance of Belgian chocolate and raspberry flavoring m...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Key Lime Pie Fudge

$ 0.00 - $ 0.00

$ 0.00

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Have you ever had fresh Key Lime Pie from Key West? Welp, here's your version in fudge form...we promise.

$ 0.00 - $ 0.00

$ 0.00

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Seasonal

Mango Habanero Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

The freshness of the mango matching the spicy and exciting flavor of the habanero pepper for a summer adventure of flavor! Made with fresh-pressed ...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Limited Batch

Firecracker Fudge

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95

Celebrate the 4th of July! Try this limited-time holiday flavor and feel the joy of the season in one bite. Made with three different flavors layer...

View full details

$ 17.95 - $ 28.95

$ 17.95