Skip to content
FREE Ground Shipping on “Fudge Only” orders over $75
Wholesale Fundraising Chocolate Ambassadors About Locations FAQ Contact Us
A stack of five handmade Key Lime Pie Slices on a white background.

FUDGE

Key Lime Pie Fudge

Zesty. Creamy. Refreshing.

$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 28.95
$ 17.95 - $ 28.95
$ 28.95
Size: 1 Pound

MAKE IT EXTRA SPECIAL

Add a Custom Gift Sleeve

Subscribe & save - 10%
Featured icon

Gluten
Free

Featured icon

Fast
Nationwide
Shipping

Featured icon

No Melt
Guaranteed

Featured icon

Hand
Crafted

Indulge in the bright, tangy essence of Key West's most iconic dessert—now captured in rich, creamy fudge. Our Key Lime Pie Fudge delivers that perfect balance of zesty citrus and buttery sweetness, transporting you straight to a tropical paradise with every bite. Handcrafted for those who crave authentic flavor in an irresistible form.
ALLERGY ALERT

All products are produced in a facility that processes nuts and may contain traces of tree nuts and peanuts.

Contains fresh cream (milk).

INGREDIENTS

Pure cane sugar, cream (milk, disodium phosphate, sodium citrate, carrageenan), glucose syrup (<4%), AA butter, glucose syrup, invert sugar syrup, concentrated lime juice (11%), concentrated lemon juice (11%), modified starch, natural citrus flavor, Acidulant: citric acid, colors: brilliant blue FCF, beta carotene. 

Shipping info
  • "Free Shipping on orders over $75 within the U.S.
  • Our fudge withstands heat over 100°F without melting; it may soften but will return to normal at room temperature or after a short chill.
  • Packed with Insulation and Refrigerant when applicable
  • Read more in our Shipping Policy"

HANDCRAFTED.
INDULGENT.
ILLEGALLY GOOD™